Stockholders' equity questions in US accounting courses cluster around two topics: what happens when a corporation buys back its own shares (treasury stock), and how it rewards shareholders (cash and stock dividends). Both are full of rules that look arbitrary until you see the one principle behind them: a company cannot make a profit or loss by trading in its own shares. This post works both topics on one company.
The Company: Summit Outdoor Co.
Summit has 100,000 shares of $1 par common stock issued. Its equity section shows Common Stock $100,000, Paid-in Capital in Excess of Par, and Retained Earnings of $900,000.
Part 1: Treasury Stock (Cost Method)
Treasury stock is the company's own stock that it has issued and then reacquired, but not retired. Under the cost method, which nearly all US textbooks use, it is recorded at what the company paid.
Buying back shares
Summit buys back 2,000 shares at $25.
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Treasury Stock | 50,000 | |
| Cash | 50,000 |
Treasury Stock is not an asset, even though it has a debit balance. A company cannot own itself. It is a contra-equity account, deducted at the bottom of stockholders' equity. Treasury shares are issued but not outstanding: they have no vote and receive no dividends.
Reissuing above cost
Summit reissues 800 shares at $30.
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Cash | 24,000 | |
| Treasury Stock (800 Γ $25) | 20,000 | |
| Paid-in Capital from Treasury Stock | 4,000 |
The $4,000 excess is not a gain. It goes to paid-in capital, never to the income statement.
Reissuing below cost, covered by paid-in capital
Summit reissues 600 shares at $21. The shortfall is 600 Γ ($25 β $21) = $2,400. Paid-in Capital from Treasury Stock has $4,000 available, so it absorbs all of it:
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Cash | 12,600 | |
| Paid-in Capital from Treasury Stock | 2,400 | |
| Treasury Stock (600 Γ $25) | 15,000 |
Reissuing below cost, beyond paid-in capital
Summit reissues 400 shares at $18. The shortfall is 400 Γ $7 = $2,800, but only $1,600 of treasury paid-in capital is left. The remaining $1,200 comes out of Retained Earnings:
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Cash | 7,200 | |
| Paid-in Capital from Treasury Stock | 1,600 | |
| Retained Earnings | 1,200 | |
| Treasury Stock (400 Γ $25) | 10,000 |
Summit still holds 200 treasury shares at $5,000. Shares outstanding: 100,000 β 200 = 99,800.
Part 2: Dividends
Three dates matter. On the declaration date the board commits, and a liability exists, so you make an entry. On the record date the shareholder list is fixed, and there is no entry. On the payment date the dividend is paid, and you make an entry.
Cash dividend
Summit declares a $0.50 per share cash dividend. Only outstanding shares receive it: 99,800 Γ $0.50 = $49,900.
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Retained Earnings (or Cash Dividends) | 49,900 | |
| Dividends Payable | 49,900 |
On the payment date: Dr Dividends Payable 49,900, Cr Cash 49,900. If a Dividends account is used, it is closed to Retained Earnings at year-end. See our closing entries guide.
Small stock dividend (under 20β25%)
Summit declares a 10% stock dividend when the market price is $28. New shares: 99,800 Γ 10% = 9,980. A small stock dividend is recorded at fair value, because shareholders see it as close to a cash distribution:
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Retained Earnings (9,980 Γ $28) | 279,440 | |
| Common Stock Dividend Distributable (9,980 Γ $1) | 9,980 | |
| Paid-in Capital in Excess of Par | 269,460 |
On distribution: Dr Common Stock Dividend Distributable 9,980, Cr Common Stock 9,980. Common Stock Dividend Distributable is an equity account, not a liability: the company owes shares, not cash.
Large stock dividend (over 20β25%)
A large stock dividend is recorded at par value, because a distribution that big lowers the market price per share. A 50% stock dividend would be 49,900 shares Γ $1 = $49,900: Dr Retained Earnings, Cr Common Stock Dividend Distributable.
Stock split
A 2-for-1 split doubles the shares and halves the par value. Total equity, and every equity account balance, stays the same. No journal entry is needed, only a memo.
Cumulative preferred stock
Suppose Summit also had 5,000 shares of $100 par, 6% cumulative preferred stock, with one year's dividend in arrears. If the board declares $90,000 in total, the preferred holders take the arrears plus the current year first: 2 Γ $30,000 = $60,000. Common shareholders receive the remaining $30,000. Dividends in arrears are not a liability until declared; they are disclosed in the notes. (Their effect on earnings per share is covered in our EPS guide.)
Common treasury stock and dividend mistakes
- Recording a gain or loss on treasury stock. Differences go to paid-in capital, then retained earnings. They never reach the income statement.
- Reissuing treasury shares at the new price. Credit Treasury Stock at the original cost per share. The difference goes to paid-in capital.
- Paying dividends on issued rather than outstanding shares. Treasury shares receive nothing.
- Valuing a small stock dividend at par. Small means fair value; large means par.
- Treating Stock Dividend Distributable as a liability. It is equity until the shares are issued.
- Journalizing a stock split. A split changes share count and par value only, so it needs a memo, not an entry.
The same principle applies under IFRS: own shares bought back are deducted from equity, and no gain or loss is recognized on them. The account names and stock-dividend thresholds above are US conventions, though. Practice the full set on Accountely's treasury stock and dividends challenges, then see how each entry flows into the statement of changes in equity.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is treasury stock recorded under the cost method?
Debit Treasury Stock and credit Cash for the price paid. Treasury Stock is a contra-equity account that reduces total stockholders' equity. When the shares are reissued, Treasury Stock is credited at the original cost and any difference goes to paid-in capital.
Can a company record a gain on treasury stock?
No. A company cannot make a profit dealing in its own shares. Differences on reissue go to Paid-in Capital from Treasury Stock, and any shortfall beyond that reduces retained earnings.
What is the difference between a small and a large stock dividend?
A small stock dividend, under about 20 to 25% of the shares outstanding, is recorded at the market value of the shares. A large stock dividend is recorded at par value. Both move amounts within equity and do not change total equity.
Does a stock split need a journal entry?
No. A split changes the number of shares and the par value per share, but not any account balance, so it is recorded with a memo entry only.